Skip to main content

The India – City Road

How to Order Indian Food for the First Time: A Shoreditch Diner’s Guide

Mild butter chicken curry, a popular first-time choice at an Indian restaurant in London

If you’ve ever stood outside a curry house on City Road, menu photo in hand, wondering how to order Indian food for the first time, you’re not alone. Every week at The India on City Road, Shoreditch, we watch first-timers freeze at the sight of forty unfamiliar dish names, unsure whether “vindaloo” means flavour or fire.

Quick Answer: Start with a shared starter, choose one mild main (korma or butter chicken are the safest bets), pick a single rice or bread, and ask your server to guide the spice level. That’s the entire formula, and the rest of this guide breaks down exactly why it works.

Who This Guide Is For

This guide is written for anyone who has never eaten at an Indian restaurant before, is dining with someone who is a beginner, or simply wants a refresher before a night out in Shoreditch, Old Street, or the wider EC1 area. Whether you’re a nervous first date, a group of colleagues from a nearby City Road office, or a visitor exploring London’s food scene, the steps below apply the same way.

What Does “Ordering Indian Food” Actually Mean?

In simple terms, ordering Indian food means choosing four things separately rather than picking one fixed dish: a protein or vegetable base, a sauce style, a spice level, and a side of rice or bread. Unlike a typical British menu with one dish per line, an Indian menu lets you combine these elements yourself, which is exactly why it can feel overwhelming at first glance.

Why Does Ordering Indian Food Feel Overwhelming for Beginners?

Indian menus are genuinely different from most British takeaway menus. There’s no single “curry” category, instead you’re choosing a protein, a sauce style, a spice level, and a side, almost like building your own meal. That’s actually good news once you understand the pattern, because it means you’re always in control of how hot, how creamy, or how light your plate turns out.

In our experience serving diners on City Road every week, the most common mistake first-timers make isn’t ordering something too spicy. It’s over-ordering rice and under-ordering flavour, or picking several dishes that all taste the same. A little structure fixes both problems.

How to Order Indian Food for the First Time: Step by Step

1. Start With a Shared Starter

Order one or two starters for the table rather than one each. Onion bhaji, vegetable samosas, or tandoori chicken are gentle, crowd-pleasing choices that ease you into the flavours without committing to a full plate of anything unfamiliar.

2. Choose a Mild or Medium Main First

Go for a korma, a butter chicken, or a mild dhansak. These are creamy, comforting, and rarely intimidating, even for someone who’s never tried our full menu before. Save the vindaloo for your third or fourth visit, once you know your own limits.

3. Pick One Rice or Bread, Not Both (Yet)

Pilau rice and garlic naan are both delicious, but ordering both on your first visit often leaves you too full to actually enjoy the main event. Choose one, then add the other next time.

4. Don’t Skip the Dal

Dal (lentil curry) is one of the best Indian dishes for someone who doesn’t like spicy food. It’s warm, mild, and pairs beautifully with almost anything else on the table, making it a safe, satisfying addition to any first order.

5. Ask, Don’t Guess, About Spice Levels

A good Indian restaurant will always adjust heat on request. At The India, our team is happy to talk you through spice levels in Indian cooking dish by dish, so please just ask rather than guessing from the menu alone.

What Is the Mildest Indian Curry to Try First?

Here’s a simple spice guide to help you decide, broken down by heat level:

Spice LevelExample DishesBest For
MildKorma, Butter Chicken, Dal, PasandaFirst-timers and spice-sensitive diners
MediumJalfrezi, Bhuna, Rogan JoshDiners who enjoy a bit of warmth
HotMadras, Vindaloo, NagaExperienced spice lovers

Should you start with mild? In almost every case, yes. You can always ask your server for extra chilli on the side, but you can’t easily undo a dish that’s too hot for your palate.

What Is a Thali, and Should You Try One?

Indian thali platter with curry, dal, rice, and bread at The India, City Road, London

If you genuinely can’t decide, a thali is your answer. A thali is a single platter featuring several small dishes, usually a curry, dal, rice, bread, and a side, giving you a proper taste of our chef’s approach to authentic Indian cooking in one order. It’s one of the most popular ways to explore a new menu without committing to just one flavour.

What Is the Difference Between Curry and Biryani?

Curry refers to a sauce-based dish, usually served with rice or bread on the side. Biryani, on the other hand, is a layered rice dish where the rice, spices, and meat or vegetables are cooked together in one pot. If you’re deciding between the two on your first visit, curry gives you more control over spice and portion size, while biryani offers a single, complete flavour experience.

Common Ordering Mistakes to Avoid

  • Ordering only naan and rice with no protein or sauce dish
  • Assuming “medium” means the same heat level at every restaurant
  • Skipping starters entirely and going straight to mains
  • Not asking your server for a recommendation; they know the kitchen best

A Local Note From City Road

Indian thali platter with curry, dal, rice, and bread at The India, City Road, London

Curry has a genuinely deep history in Britain. Chicken tikka masala was famously described as a “true British national dish” by then Foreign Secretary Robin Cook back in 2001, and Greater London alone is now home to more Indian restaurants than Delhi and Mumbai combined, according to Historic UK’s account of British curry culture. Shoreditch and the wider EC1 area around Old Street and City Road sit right in the middle of that legacy, and Indian food remains one of the most searched-for cuisines by both locals and visitors staying near Angel and Moorgate.

At The India, 20 City Rd, London EC1Y 2AJ, we see a large number of first-time diners every month, often before or after a night out in Shoreditch, and we’ve built our menu and service around making that first experience an easy, welcoming one within London’s most diverse dining scenes.

Key Takeaway

Knowing how to order Indian food for the first time really comes down to four things: a shared starter, one mild main, a single rice or bread, and a willingness to ask your server for guidance. Once you’ve got that pattern down, the rest of the menu becomes exciting rather than overwhelming.

If you’re ready to put this guide into practice, we’d love to welcome you to The India on City Road for your first, unforgettable Indian dining experience, and see our vegetarian menu picks if you’re dining meat-free. Book your table today and let our team guide you through the menu in person.

Frequently Asked Questions:

How do I order Indian food for the first time?

Start with a shared starter like onion bhaji, choose a mild main such as butter chicken or korma, add rice or bread, and ask your server about spice levels.

What is the mildest Indian curry to try first?

Korma, butter chicken, and mild dhansak are widely considered the gentlest options for first-time diners, as they’re creamy and low in heat.

What is a thali?

A thali is a single platter with several small dishes, typically a curry, dal, rice, bread, and a side, giving you a well-rounded introduction to Indian cuisine in one order.

What is the difference between curry and biryani?

Curry refers to a sauce-based dish served with rice or bread on the side, while biryani is a layered rice dish cooked together with spices, meat, or vegetables in one pot.

Is Indian food always very spicy?

No. Spice level is adjustable at most Indian restaurants, including The India, and dishes like korma, dal, and butter chicken are naturally mild.

What is vindaloo, and is it too hot for beginners?

Vindaloo is a fiery, tangy curry originating from Goa. It’s genuinely spicy, so it’s best saved until you’ve tried a few milder dishes first.

What is paneer, and is it a good option for vegetarians?

Paneer is a fresh, mild Indian cheese that holds its shape when cooked. It’s a popular and satisfying choice for vegetarians new to Indian menus.

Should I order a starter before my main course at an Indian restaurant?

Yes. Sharing one or two starters for the table is the traditional and most enjoyable way to begin an Indian meal, and it eases you into the flavours before your main dish arrives.